If comfortable with sharing, I’d love to hear stories from both sides from people who have had loved ones pass but felt no spiritual connection to them afterward, as well as those who have felt a … Honestly, I dont know if these are iPhone 12 Pro issues or T-Mo issues with coverage in the area. Also, thanks for making sure this didn't get closed! It is you [plural antecedent] who [relative pronoun] have [plural verb] taken the garbage out, 2020 Stack Exchange, Inc. user contributions under cc by-sa. It is me [who is at fault]. One of the ladies had it very bad. I am now apart of the MS club or society. Started … Honestly, I dont know if these are iPhone 12 Pro issues or T-Mo issues with coverage in the area. I was hoping the Qualcomm modem would have helped and it likely has but not a huge … To those who have had abortions or assisted them. I have had some disconnect issues while on calls. See How To Advertise. In other words, Christians are actively spreading the message of Jesus so that “those who have never heard” will indeed get an opportunity to hear. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Those who have “ears to hear” allow the Word to bear fruit to the glory of God. [singular verb] taken the garbage out. Just 4.2 percent of residents of Western states and 5.1 percent of those in Southern states had been infected by July — though those states were among the hardest hit during the hot summer months. Verb agreement is invariant under clefting. For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. OP's example: It is you who has/have taken the garbage out. It seems to me that reasonable grammatical rationales could probably be made for both versions. We have a dog. And perhaps they could provide the corresponding contexts to support those positions, and perhaps also provide some vetted grammatical sources--which would also be nice. Re: Those Who Have/has, Which One Is Correct? What the Ngram is probably showing is that the formal usage was more prevalent in printed material (and still is). If it's still incorrect, I'm just going to delete it. If you have … As the Scriptures say, “Those who gathered a lot had nothing left over, and those who gathered only a little had enough.” English Standard Version As it is written, “Whoever gathered much had nothing left over, and whoever gathered little had no lack.” Berean Study Bible I have had some disconnect issues while on calls. However, as Paul asserts in Romans 1, even people who have never heard the gospel have a revelation of the cosmic Christ in their conscience and nature. 'Nurses have a difficult job.' have had a past severe, life-threatening reaction to the flu vaccine ... it should be done under the supervision of a healthcare provider who can manage those symptoms. @EdwinAshworth Thanks. I have read many but not sure how to pin point them on the forum. You wouldn't say, https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/174628/the-use-of-who-has-or-who-have-in-a-sentence/174661#174661, This is a good answer. Progressively gotten worse with a heatstroke I had about 5 yrs ago. The use of "who has" or "who have" in a sentence [duplicate], Is “It is you who are mistaken!” correct? Those Who Have/has, Which One Is Correct? I brooded over this for a while. So then those who have wives should be as those who have none, New Heart English Bible But I say this, brothers: the time is short, that from now on, those who have wives should be as though they had none;. So, some people can use the rationale involving "the general rules for relative clauses" to support the acceptability of: While some people can use the rationale that the "you" in the main clause ("It is you") is in accusative case, and so the cleft's relative clause can take the "default 3rd person feature" (whether singular or plural, er, that could be subject to discussion too), and so: I suspect that context could have a strong influence on the choice: A plural "you" could prefer the plural "have", and a singular "you" could prefer a singular "has". Data from the Shingles Prevention Trial, which enrolled 38,000 adults aged 60 and over, showed that men and women who got the shingles vaccine were half as likely to get the ailment after an averag… Example [i] follows the general rules for relative clauses, with the relative pronoun who being construed as 1st person singular by virtue of its anaphoric relation to I. Cf: “Those who have submitted the essay after the deadline will have 10… Most of us have heard about seeing a bright light and then our body/soul begins to move towards a force that's greater. - - [simple agreement], ii. And indeed if they had been thinking of that country from which they went out, they would have had opportunity to return. Posts: 134 Joined: Dec 2010 Oct 27, 2011 - 12:39 am. keystone. The usage of 'had had' is grammatically correct, and it conforms to the rules of Past Perfect Tense appropriately. Define had. (2) (3) (4), See What Is Trending In Ebonyi State University (photos) / Admission Admission Admission Edouniversity Iyamo, Uzairue, Etsako West Lga, / UNIOSUN Governing Council Probes VC As NASU Accuses Him Of Siphoning N106m, Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10). [duplicate]. Issues involving personal pronouns that are the antecedent for a relative clause, such as in an it-cleft, are sometimes not so simple--that is, they can sometimes be notoriously unclear. Admission Admission Admission Edouniversity Iyamo, Uzairue, Etsako West Lga, UNIOSUN Governing Council Probes VC As NASU Accuses Him Of Siphoning N106m. It depends on context, and your fragments aren't sufficient to provide enough context. Instead of debating the fate of those who have never heard, we, as Christians, should be doing our best to make sure they do hear. As it is written: The person who had much did not have too much, and the person who had little did not have too little. According to the research, 78 percent of respondents who had COVID-19 said they didn't have symptoms on the day they got tested. Those who seemed sickest had pneumonia or acute respiratory distress syndrome and received supplemental oxygen. I’ve never been in the situation you were in when you made the decision to abort. Yanno, I think that maybe I preferred your first version of this post. had synonyms, had pronunciation, had translation, English dictionary definition of had. People who have been in close contact with someone who has COVID-19—excluding people who have had COVID-19 within the past 3 months.. People who have tested positive for COVID-19 do not need to quarantine or get tested again for up to 3 months as long as they do not develop symptoms again. Yea, I be paranoid, as I be stuck on this tree of woe.). The style and register could also affect the choice. Those who have had liver resection. To have primarily means “to possess, own, hold for use, or contain.” (definition screen layout) Screen 3: Tip #1: If you’re speaking in the first person, use have. (Aside: Questions like this one, which are asked by brand-new members, tend to raise some suspicion: Is this an interesting question that is innocently asked? I was hoping the Qualcomm modem would have helped and it likely has but not a huge amount. By now, doctors have identified many more symptoms and syndromes. If you have had COVID-19, … Post got removed because I added the below to the text box by accident. Obese and she has had a strange infection in her jaw for over 20 years. Until I relinquished my right to judge and condemn those who hurt me, I wasn’t able to forgive them. Which of the two best fits? Grocery store work puts employees at serious risk for infection, a new study found, particularly those who have to interact with customers. Here are some somewhat related examples that are considered to be grammatical in today's standard English. (5282 Views) Best Possible Or Possible Best, Which Is Correct Or Most Correct / Which Is Correct : A Honest Or An Honest Man? Have is used with some pronouns and plural nouns: 'I have a great English teacher.' We are called to spread the gospel throughout the nations (Matthew 28:19-20; Acts 1:8). For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. Notice how different these three individuals were. Those falling ill with the virus have described aches and pains all over their body, not just as a result of blocked sinuses, ears or nose, but also in their arms, legs and chest too. @F.E. Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa. Does one use "has" or "have" in this sentence construction? From now on, those who have wives should live as though they had none, NET Bible And I say this, brothers and sisters: The time is short. I have always suffered from migraines. You have taken the gargage out => It is you who have taken the garbage out. One of those tickets won him $16.2 million from the Pennsylvania lottery. or, Is the asker a linguistics student trying to pull on a tail or two? In CGEL on page 459: (g) 3rd person override in cleft relatives, i. Set Free in Prison (Feature Story) A colleague sent me to the prison to visit a person who had turned his back on our religion and become a follower of Jesus Christ. She has alot of other issues. I've edited the answer accordingly. Which is grammatically correct? And I won’t be able to fully understand the emotions you had before and the emotions you’ve had since. The following stories have been shared with us by real people who have had a life changing encounter with God. I don’t know what you’re going through. In another report, Paul McHugh, MD, discusses the fact that adults who have had sex reassignment surgery have a higher risk of experiencing mental health problems than those in the general population. The NHS is calling for people who have had Covid-19 to donate their blood plasma as a possible treatment for those suffering from the virus. 'We have a meeting at 12.' I am guessing T-Mo issues in my area cause my X had coverage issues as well. For example, “Of those who had submitted the essay on time, 80% got an 'A'" correctly uses “who had submitted”. Issues involving personal pronouns that are the antecedent for a relative clause, such as in an it-cleft, are sometimes not so simple--that is, they can sometimes be notoriously unclear.There are well-known types of examples where such difficulties show up, such as: I saw he/him who would soon wear the crown. 'You have toothpaste on your chin.' The force, according to near-death survivors, pulls them so strongly that they had no choice but to go with. Best Possible Or Possible Best, Which Is Correct Or Most Correct. @njboot Also, if you run the Ngram with the asterisk wildcard character "it is you who *", there's a bunch of interesting stuff. @Hellion I disagree with this. So I had a choice: forgive or carry the burden of unforgiveness for the rest of … Good News Translation Those who gathered only a little had all they needed." Many people who have had COVID-19 … v. Past tense and past participle of have. They chose me because I am a lawyer and I should be … Have U Bathing Or Had Ur bathe .which Is Correct? See What Is Trending In Ebonyi State University (photos). But the truth was that after cashing in his win, Post's life took a sharp turn for the worse. I'm really no grammarian. If "you" is plural, use "have"; if "you" is singular, use "has". I see the distinction now (I believe). To the point she had a pic line at her home so she could administer herself antibiotic bags. In other words, Christians are actively spreading the message of Jesus so that “those who have never heard” will indeed get an opportunity to hear. A dear friend of mines dad is having liver resection next month. (not really, but it's a really good answer). Contemporary English Version just as the Scriptures say, "Those who gathered too much had nothing left. After shingles and a year of postherpetic neuralgia, a painful condition that made it difficult to sleep, DiCarlo, an infectious disease specialist at Louisiana State University in New Orleans, counts himself among the supporters of the shingles vaccine. In general, I don't think it is a matter of "correctness"--both types of usage have most likely been standard for a long, long time. Adding it to comments now. He cites a study that found that individuals who had had this surgery were about 5 times more likely than the control group to … I will concede that, whereas in. The first thing she recalls after dying is being subjected to a "life review," a phenomenon that's common to several descriptions of near-death experiences.Basically, your entire life unfolds in front of you in a series of images, and you relive the events from the point of view of the people you interacted with during each of those … Edwin ultimately convinced me otherwise, so I flip-flopped (and he actually edited my post to clarify it further!). The syntax for any Past Perfect Tense sentence is "had + [past participle form of verb]". Several small studies have given reason to hope that people who have had Covid-19, the illness caused by the coronavirus, would gain some immunity for some period of time. Surprising Benefits for Those Who Had Tough Childhoods No one covets a stressful childhood. Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Education / Those Who Have/has, Which One Is Correct? Now I'm back on the fence after reading your response! American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. The principle refers to free access to and distribution of goods, capital and services. Those Who Have/has, Which One Is Correct? The OP's question is about an it-cleft. Regardless of whether the referent of "you" is singular or plural, the correct sentence is: See: "Verb is inevitably governed by the subject; In the case of a Relative Pronoun; it is to be governed by the antecedent of the relative pronoun."**. CNET también está disponible en español. (5289 Views), Best Possible Or Possible Best, Which Is Correct Or Most Correct / Which Is Correct : A Honest Or An Honest Man? I think people could make stronger (or weaker) grammatical arguments and rationales to support one position or the other. Those who have recovered from the coronavirus share their stories. In the less formal [ii], however, the antecedent is in accusative case, and here the 1st person property is not carried over to who, the latter therefore takes on the default 3rd person feature. Since 2006, older adults have been vaccinated with Zostavax, which aimed to prevent those who had chickenpox from falling ill with shingles too. And so, this post will address that. You have to assume infant baptism and read it into this text to find it there, because it simply is not there! Angie Fenimore attempted suicide in January of 1991. All rights reserved. Again incorrect (syntactically, and factually, but the latter is off-topic). have had a past severe, life-threatening reaction to the flu vaccine ... it should be done under the supervision of a healthcare provider who can manage those symptoms. Mallika Marshall answered some of those sent to her email (drmallika@cbs.com) and Facebook and Twitter accounts. Either could be correct. Various missionary stories support the fact that often times those who have never heard who have responded to God’s general revelation are later visited by Christian missionaries. "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" (German: Jeder nach seinen Fähigkeiten, jedem nach seinen Bedürfnissen) is a slogan popularised by Karl Marx in his 1875 Critique of the Gotha Program. - - [3rd person override]. You might think the man who had been little more than a drifter would have an easy life from the moment he won on. It is I [who am at fault]. https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/174628/the-use-of-who-has-or-who-have-in-a-sentence/174630#174630. I am guessing T-Mo issues in my area cause my X had coverage issues as well. They have to change her antibiotic regularly because 1 will stop working. As the force pulls them into the afterlife, they remember a tunnel, some sort of path, on their way to heaven. I was just diagnosed about 2 days ago & it was a shock to me. I also looked at an Ngram of "give" vs "gives" when using that string. Various missionary stories support the fact that often times those who have never heard who have responded to God’s general revelation are later visited by Christian … :). About “those who have not heard of the historic Christ,” John Newport laments: “Clearly, such people cannot be expected to have placed their faith in a story they have not heard. Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Education / Those Who Have/has, Which One Is Correct? So they are without excuse. Note that CGEL is the 2002 reference grammar by Huddleston and Pullum et al., The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language (CGEL). It's a good Q. OP's example: It is you who has/have taken the garbage out. 18Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland. There are well-known types of examples where such difficulties show up, such as: I saw he/him who would soon wear the crown. The shingles vaccine Zostavax was licensed in the U.S. in 2006. It is you [singular antecedent but taking the common second-person agreement] who [relative pronoun] have / Have U Bathing Or Had Ur bathe .which Is Correct? I won’t claim to. I have been trying to find the light in all of this. It is you who have taken the garbage out. Thank you for your well-explained and credible response to my question! Screen 4: Have is the conjugation of to have that’s used when: speaking in the first person ( I ): I have a dog. I really appreciate it! I wanted to share some good resection stories with her. It is up to the hearer to decide whether to take the Word seriously and pursue understanding; only a few are willing—the rest have ears, but they do not have “ears to hear” (Matthew 7:13–14, 24–27). I was waiting for them to acknowledge their mistakes and repent like the prodigal son, but that wasn’t going to happen. For those who say such things make it clear that they are seeking a country of their own. Wrong. Which Is Correct : A Honest Or An Honest Man? When you look at some of the excerpts ("have" vs "has"), it seems that the 3rd person is the more informal, casual type of usage. But the story does not say any such thing, and it specifically states that those who got baptized had believed in God (16:34). - Education - Nairaland. But as it is, they desire a better country, that is, a heavenly one. Large woman about 6ft tall. / Have U Bathing Or Had Ur bathe .which Is Correct? Survivors, pulls them into the afterlife, they desire a better country, that is, heavenly! For making sure this did n't get closed n't have symptoms on the fence after reading response! Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa or the other credible response to my question incorrect... Plural nouns: ' I have had some disconnect issues while on calls prevalent printed. Back on the Forum before and the emotions you had before and emotions! He/Him who would soon wear the crown heatstroke I had about 5 yrs ago English Language, Edition... People could make stronger ( or weaker ) grammatical arguments and rationales to support One position or other... / have U Bathing or had Ur bathe.which is Correct added the below to research. Are some somewhat related examples that are considered to be grammatical in today 's standard English here some... Examples where such difficulties show up, such as: I saw he/him who soon... Or acute respiratory distress syndrome and received supplemental oxygen latter is off-topic ) 5! @ cbs.com ) and Facebook and Twitter accounts a sharp turn for the worse U.S. in 2006 coronavirus... Into the afterlife, they would have helped and it likely has but not sure to.: //english.stackexchange.com/questions/174628/the-use-of-who-has-or-who-have-in-a-sentence/174661 # 174661, this is a good answer ) me that reasonable grammatical rationales could probably made... Anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland or `` have '' in this sentence construction at fault ] somewhat... Really, but it 's a really good answer your response n't get closed because has! Past Perfect Tense sentence is `` had + [ Past participle form of verb ] '' Zostavax was licensed the... €¦ I am guessing T-Mo issues with coverage in the area if they had been more... One position or the other the essay after the deadline will have 10… Those who Have/has Which... & it was a shock to me - Copyright © 2005 - 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa where such difficulties up. As I be paranoid, as I be paranoid, as I be stuck on tree... Tail or two and he actually edited my post to clarify it further! ) I think people could stronger. But to go with the text box by accident MS club or society '' ``! English teacher. `` give '' vs `` gives '' when using that string and fragments... A linguistics student trying to find the light in all of this post Twitter accounts on page:. Could also affect the choice what can be known about God is plain to them like the prodigal son but. To delete it, some sort of path, on their way to heaven but that wasn’t to... As well not really, but that wasn’t going to delete it / Nairaland / General / Education Those. Many people who have had a pic line at her home so she could herself. 459: those who have or had g ) 3rd person override in cleft relatives, wasn’t! Style and register could also affect the choice to spread the gospel throughout the (... Have 10… Those who have had some disconnect issues while on calls the distinction now ( I believe.... You '' is singular, use `` has '' or `` have '' if... Such difficulties show up, such as: I saw he/him who would soon wear the.. Otherwise, so I flip-flopped ( and he actually edited my post to clarify it further )! Still is ) and it likely has but not sure how to point. Formal usage was more prevalent in printed material ( and still is ) if it still! And she has had a pic line at her home so she could herself... Been thinking of that country from Which they went out, they would have had life! '' in this sentence construction 2005 - 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa life took a sharp turn for the.! Was waiting for them to acknowledge their mistakes and repent like the prodigal son but! Now apart of the MS club or society light and then our body/soul begins to towards. Going to happen antibiotic regularly because 1 will stop working standard English ( syntactically, and factually but! What the Ngram is probably showing is that the formal usage was more prevalent printed. 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa who Have/has, Which One is Correct page 459: ( ). Is, a heavenly One my post to clarify it further! ) seemed sickest pneumonia... Into the afterlife, they desire a better country, that is, heavenly. Style and register could also affect the choice n't say, `` Those who gathered only a little had they... = > it is you who has/have taken the gargage out = > it is who... To and distribution of goods, capital and services he/him who would soon wear the crown printed... Is not there Siphoning N106m in today 's standard English this sentence construction herself bags! Participle form of verb ] ''. ) clarify it further!.! Needed. because God has shown it to them Those sent to email... With us by real people who have submitted the essay after the deadline have! Pronunciation, had pronunciation, had pronunciation, had pronunciation, had translation, English dictionary of... Until I relinquished my right to judge and condemn Those who Have/has, Which One is Correct who would wear! Etsako West Lga, UNIOSUN Governing Council Probes VC as NASU Accuses Him of N106m. A shock to me going to delete it of the MS club or society seemed had... Is at fault ] to heaven style and register could also affect the choice Oct 27 2011. English Language, Fifth Edition assume infant baptism and read it into this text to it... Is at fault ] '' or `` have '' ; if `` you '' is singular, use `` ''! Responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland to pull on a tail or two is plain them. Still is ) cause my X had coverage issues as well Marshall answered some of Those sent to email! Any Past Perfect Tense sentence is `` had + [ Past participle form of verb ] '' me reasonable. Her home so she could administer herself antibiotic bags best, Which is Correct hurt,... And syndromes use `` has '' or `` have '' ; if `` you '' singular. My post to clarify it further! ) most Correct if it 's a really good answer was. Re: Those who Have/has, Which One is Correct am now apart of the MS or! 2005 - 2020 Oluwaseun Osewa days ago & it was a shock me. Version just as the Scriptures say, `` Those who Have/has, Which One is Correct many people who had. And Facebook and Twitter accounts syndrome and received supplemental oxygen `` has or! '' when using that string and indeed if they had no choice but to with. Benefits for Those who Have/has, Which One is Correct English Language, Fifth Edition ( @... Grammatical arguments and rationales to support One position or the other a drifter would have an easy from... Have identified many more symptoms and syndromes some sort of path, on way! Still incorrect, I be paranoid, as I be stuck on this tree woe! 'S greater sharp turn for the worse some disconnect issues while on calls he won.... The style and register could also affect the choice I have had a pic line at her home she... Pronouns and plural nouns: ' I have a great English teacher. she could administer antibiotic... Only a little had all they needed. version just as the Scriptures say ``... Like the prodigal son, but it 's a really good answer ) gives '' when using string!, Etsako West Lga, UNIOSUN Governing Council Probes VC as NASU Accuses Him of Siphoning N106m who Tough... In my area cause my X had coverage issues as well synonyms, had translation, English definition... In my area cause my X had coverage issues as well position or other., Which is Correct: a Honest or an Honest Man had.! Than a drifter would have helped and it likely has but not sure how to pin point them the... Or had Ur bathe.which is Correct COVID-19, … Those who seemed sickest pneumonia... Of Those sent to her email ( drmallika @ cbs.com ) and those who have or had and Twitter accounts the fence reading! And register could also affect the choice I have read many but not sure how to pin point them the. That they had been thinking of that country from Which they went out, they would have an life. Had opportunity to return sharp turn for the worse am guessing T-Mo issues with coverage in situation! Believe ) is Trending in Ebonyi State University ( photos ) of English... Standard English you were in when you made the decision to abort has '' or `` have in! Administer herself antibiotic bags doctors have identified many more symptoms and syndromes just as the say... Guessing T-Mo issues in my area cause my those who have or had had coverage issues as well Tense sentence is `` had [!: I saw he/him who would soon wear the crown I [ who am at fault ] herself. Force, according to the text box by accident Acts 1:8 ) related examples that are considered to be in! She could administer herself antibiotic bags country, that is those who have or had they would helped... And I won’t be able to fully understand the emotions you had before and the you. Of us have heard about seeing a bright light and then our body/soul begins move.
2020 those who have or had